There is the spacetime manifold, and the fundamental properties are pinned directly to it. The primary or immediate determination of nature is the abstract universality of its selfexternality, its unmediated indifference, i. Do past and future exist in the same way as the present or is only the present real. Starting by the notions of space and time, of fundamental importance for the evolution for the global knowledge of children already in the primary school, we arrive to indications about the teaching of relativity in high school and university. Hans reichenbach, a philosopher of science who was one of five students in einsteins first seminar on the general theory of relativity, became einsteins bulldog, defending the theory against criticism from philosophers, physicists, and popular commentators. Instead of dictating socalled laws of reason to the scientist, this modern philosopher proceeds by analyzing scientific methods and results. My purpose in this paper is to bring some order to the resulting surfeit. Reichenbach 1958 is an effective introduction to the philosophy of space and time from a logical empiricist perspective. Professor reichenbach, known for his many contributions to logic and the philosophy of science, addresses this book to a wider audience. All we have is an elastic net of probability relations. We know many circumstances in which the length is altered.
Space is no more than relations between objects or a property of objects. There is no first space nor first time, nowhere and at no time did nature begin and as such it will never end. Books by hans reichenbach author of the philosophy of. Hans reichenbach, entry in the internet encyclopedia of philosophy. While such ideas have been central to philosophy from its inception, the philosophy of space and time was both an inspiration for and a central aspect of. He seems to have little in the way of agenda or isms to tout, nor is he inclined to spend much ink on rehashing historical debates or trivial examples. Keywords spacetime substantivalism supersubstantivalism monism space and time, so far from being the least selfsubsistent of things, are in truth in their indissoluble union the ultimate reality in its simplest and barest. Einstein, kant, and the relativized a priori michael friedman abstract i argue that einsteins creation of both special and general relativity instantiates reichenbachs conception of the relativized a priori. As such, an infinity of worlds existed prior, exist now, and will exist afterward. Taylor, spatial and temporal analogies and the concept of identity einsteins dreams pp.
Philosophy of space and time university of notre dame. The philosophy of space and time hans reichenbach, maria. In part, this is so because griinbaum has chosen a problem basic both to philosophy and to the natural sciences the nature of space and time. The philosophy of space and time hans reichenbach, maria reichenbach translator a brilliantly clear and penetrating exposition of developments in physical science and mathematics brought about by the advent of noneuclidean geometries, including indepth coverage of the foundations of geometry, the theory of time, einsteins theory of relativity and its consequences, other key topics. I present a discussion of some open issues in the philosophy of spacetime theories. What can we learn about the ontology of space and time. It begins and ends at all spaces and times, but it just as much does not. This even extends to grand reimaginings of spacetime, though this is still. The philosophy of space and time is more intimately connected with the nature of psychical theory than any other branch of philosophy. It was promptly recognized to be one of the few major works in the philosophy of the natural sciences of this generation. For example, the temperature in a can differ from the temperature in b. As part of this he proposed a three part model of time in language, involving speech time, event time. Hans reichenbachs most popular book is the philosophy of space and time.
The hole argument stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The analysis of the hole argument provides philosophers of physics a convenient template when they are trying to decide if something is a gauge freedom or not. Truth and necessity in temporal perspective by nicholas rescher in richard gales the philosophy of time. Reichenbach died unexpectedly of a heart attack on april 9, 1953. Professor reichenbach traces the failures of the systems to psychological causes.
Where space, time, physics, and philosophy convergean everymans introduction to an unsung hero of philosophy 2007. Sklar, space, time, and spacetime, chapter 3 a classic overview of the substantivalism vs relationalism debate the leibnizclarke correspondence, reprinted in huggett, space from zeno to einstein, chapter 8. Where space, time, physics, and philosophy converge an everymans introduction to an unsung hero of philosophy will turner western kentucky university. Their search for certainty and for moral directives led them to accept pseudosolutions. In this paper a pedagogical, but rigorous introduction to the key concepts of relativity is presented. The rise of scientific philosophy hans reichenbach, hans. He tells us how to find our way through this world without resorting to unjustifiable beliefs or. Reichenbach h 1928 the philosophy of space and time new york. What are kants reasons for telling us that space and time are not reducible to categories, that is, that there are two sorts of a priori forms. A brilliantly clear and penetrating exposition of developments in physical science and mathematics brought about by the advent of noneuclidean geometries, including indepth coverage of the foundations of geometry, the theory of time, einsteins theory of relativity and its consequences, other key topics. While such ideas have been central to philosophy from its inception, the philosophy of space and time was both an inspiration for and a central aspect of early analytic philosophy. Several additional papers, on quantum theory and gravitation, are pending publication. This book was first published in 1970, with a second edition in 1985. Mar 17, 2003 the philosophy of space and time by hans reichenbach, 9780486604435, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
I present a discussion of some open issues in the philosophy of space time theories. The philosophy of space and time by hans reichenbach. The philosophy of space and time free ebook download as pdf. What is the difference between past, present, and future. The hole argument has played a role in the growing recognition in philosophy of physics of the importance of gauge transformations. My task is not to survey the many answers on record. The philosophy of space and time 1928h, reichenbachs most widely read, most elegant, and least original work on physics, combines an extension to spacetime theories of helmholtzs and poincares conventionalism about geometry with a description of einsteins special and general relativity theories from the point of view of the axiomatization, much of which it repeats. Books by hans reichenbach author of the philosophy of space. Philosophical problems of space and time wikipedia.
Leibniz and clark horwich, on the existence of time, space and spacetime on the bucket argument, and. With respect to the problem of reality, space and time are not different from the other physical concepts. In this course we will examine philosophical questions such as these, concerning space and time, and their 20th century offspring. It is recognized as a major work in the philosophy of the natural sciences. Le poidevin 1999 surveys some of the most important areas in the metaphysics of time during a crucial renaissance of that field. The philosophy of space and time dover books on physics 9780486604435. Philosophy 454 philosophy of space and time mwf 1212. Reichenbach proposes the following problem, discussed in the philosophy of space and time. Tokarevsky2 1 institute of physics of nas of ukraine 2 institute of chernobyl problems of ukraine abstract in the paper the space time problem is considered as it is seen in the informational conception the information as. The founders of this movementespecially carnap, reichenbach and schlick were. The philosophy of space and time by hans reichenbach, 9780486604435, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Richmond 2003 tries to survey all the major strands in.
Hans reichenbach stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Time, space, and metaphysics engages with major philosophical questions concerning time and space, a framework for the investigation being provided by the debate between the absolutists and the relationists, so between newton and leibniz, and their followers. The hans reichenbach papers, archives of scientific papers, university of pittsburgh. In contrast, a relationist would deny that space exists independently of objects. David bourget western ontario david chalmers anu, nyu area editors. Philosophy of space and time is the branch of philosophy concerned with the issues surrounding the ontology, epistemology, and character of space and time. Reichenbachs ideas about causality and probability are so intertwined that. He finds answers to the ageold questions of space, time, causality, and life. One is a chapter on philosophy of space and time by john norton from a text consisting of chapters by members of the pittsburgh hps program and philosophy department called introduction to the philosophy of science, edited by m.
I do this by showing how the original kantian conception actually contributes to the development. Introduction to the philosophy of time and space, chapter ii, sections 1, 2 pages 1 by bas van fraassen. Curved empty spacetime as the building material of the physical world. Philosophical problems of space and time springerlink. Introduction to philosophy of space and time monday, january 14. Emphasis is put on the ontological nature of space and time, the relation between determinism and predictability,the origin of irreversibleprocesses in an expandinguniverse, and the compatibility of relativity and quantum mechanics. What can we learn about the ontology of space and time from.
Walls of text, i provide lots of context but please focus on boldeditalicized sections. The entry metaphysics from sep stanford encyclopedia of philosophy also deals with space and time, see chapter 3. To give you a good working knowledge of the philosophical debates about space and time and how physics bears on those debates. It is on account of its being selfexternality, that space constitutes collaterality of a comple tely ideal nature. Hans reichenbachs writings on space, time, and motion. A and b theories of time dean zimmerman, the a theory of time, the b theory of time, and. The philosophy of space and time 1928h, reichenbachs most widely. To give you the ability to think about these debates and other, related, debates we wont have time to discuss from the spacetime point of view. Is the length of a rod altered when the rod is moved from one point of space, say a, to another point, say b. A systematic history in the philosophy of space and time by niko strobach kluwer academic, 1998. Hans reichenbach has 35 books on goodreads with 1846 ratings. Speculative philosophers offered answers at a time when science had not yet provided the means to give true answers. Rise of scientific philosophy by hans reichenbach, hardcover.
More, i suspect that the author of the entry, probably an expert in metaphysics, is not familiar with modern physics. By such a way the utmost important in physics notions, space and time. Interesting considerations related to fascinating topics, like the evolution of the concept of spacetime and the unusual amazing peculiarities emerging by the extensions of relativity, will be done. It is ten years since adolf griinbaum published the first edition of this book. The expanding spacetime theory foundation is located on the web at publishing editor ted wadman. Schedule of lectures \the philosophy of space, time and spacetime dr.
491 43 612 324 37 1185 1245 1140 38 904 659 119 67 98 840 1276 924 981 255 675 429 586 1471 1178 395 413 1281 489 932 935 422 599 1142 132 1330 694 1149 840 1140